X AVISO DE COOKIES: Este sitio web hace uso de cookies con la finalidad de recopilar datos estadísticos anónimos de uso de la web, así como la mejora del funcionamiento y personalización de la experiencia de navegación del usuario. Aceptar Más información
sensationalist pres

Judging an Article by its Cover

L. SAPIÑA. 01/05/2013 Time magazine strongly criticised for cancer cure claims. Never let facts spoil a good headline

Juzgar un artículo por la portada

VALENCIA. Never let facts spoil a good headline. Or a good cover, we may add. This sentence, often used to talk about the gutter press, fits this case: in early April, Time magazine shocked the world with a cover that featured a full-page message in capital letters: «HOW TO CURE CANCER». This headline incorporated an asterisk (*) -which is not very common- that led to this note: «Yes, it's now possible- thanks to new cancer dream teams that are delivering better results faster».

Claiming on the cover page that now it is indeed possible to cure cancer is overstating the facts, and -ultimately- false. We can imagine the kind of excitement this type of headlines arouse among cancer patients and their relatives, who are waiting for an ultimate cure for cancer. And this way, while most oncologists repeat once and again that there is no magic formula and that what we need to do is keep on working in knowing better each one of the many signs of the disease, covers like this one destroy any attempt to approach the topic seriously. 

The article -which inside the magazine is entitled «The Conspiracy To End Cancer»- is written by Bill Saporito and introduces the topic on a warlike note: «It works as one great armed force, attacking by the equivalent of air and land and sea and stealth, and we think we're going to take it out with what? A lab-coated sniper?» Saportio quotes the MIT researcher Philip Sharp to emphasise that the disease «is much more complex than we have been treating it» and, therefore «it will take not one hero but many.

Sharp - a Nobel Prize-winning molecular biologist who studies the genetic causes of cancer - is recruiting special-forces units to fight back». These special force units are the dream teams the cover refers to and which have been promoted for four years by Stand Up to Cancer, -an organisation devoted to fight cancer that was founded by people linked to the entertainment industry who are capable of raising funds-.

Of course, generously funded first-rate research teams would definitely contribute to a fast progress in cancer treatment. In this sense, they are indeed remarkable and much needed projects. However, directly linking the existence of these groups to some kind of magic formula that cures cancer is, at the very least, exaggerating and shows a lack of rigour.

This is why some media have raised their voice against the way the magazine approached the topic. In an article published in Slate.com, the journalist and writer Seth Mnookin considers it a good candidate to be chosen worst cover of the year. Paul Raeburn also analyses the cover in an article for Tracker, the MIT's blog Knight Science Journalism Program. In Spanish media, José Luis de la Serna -physician and El Mundo collaborator- branded the cover «excessive».

Full text available at Mètode's website


Lucía Sapiña. The Two Cultures Observatory


Comparte esta noticia


Actualmente no hay comentarios para esta noticia.

Si quieres dejarnos un comentario rellena el siguiente formulario con tu nombre, tu dirección de correo electrónico y tu comentario.

Escribe un comentario

Tu email nunca será publicado o compartido. Los campos con * son obligatorios. Los comentarios deben ser aprobados por el administrador antes de ser publicados.